I recall the story as well....where a rather liberal college student talked about the need to redistribute wealth, because there were so many who just didn't have what others had. So, the logically minded teacher told her, what a great idea, and oh, by the way, those straight A's you are earning? Well we have some students who are getting D's and F's, and really could use some A's. So we're going to take some of your A's, and of course the GPA associated with them, and give them to much more needy students. The Straight-A Student was agast at the thought. I wonder why??