I don't like the idea. Basically you are simply advocating dominance by force or threat of force. I think you would have to wind up with a bunch of sullen and resentful men, since they've been humiliated, and every day they spend under your command would just be rubbing in the fact that as long as you are around, they are powerless little schmucks and you are The Man.
Sounds to me like the perfect recipe for a fragging.
I'm pretty sure you have to add a lot of flattery, encouragement, petty rewards, constructive criticism, humour, care and concern to motivate these guys to band together around you, much less convince them that it wouldn't be very nice to shoot you in the back in a firefight.
But I don't know if you ever read the book "Currahee!" It's the memoir of a WWII American paratrooper, and he describes an incident pretty much out of your kind of philosophy. Their beloved sergeant was transferred and they got a new guy nobody liked, a small, wiry hiillbilly from Arkansas. Everyone bitched and disrespected the new sergeant, so he took all the guys out behind a building, took off his shirt so there was no insignia of rank and started fighting the biggest man in the outfit, beat the shit out of him, and proceeded one at a time to take on all the other guys, beating the shit out of each of them too. So I guess your philosophy kinda worked for him too.