Was It Worth It?
We don?t know the final extent of the Democratic losses yet. But we do know the questions that liberals and Democrats will be asking themselves tomorrow morning. Was it all worthwhile? Was the 111th Congress?s flurry of legislative activity worth the backlash it helped create? Were the health care bill and the stimulus worth handing John Boehner the gavel in the House of the Representatives? Did it make sense to push and push and then keep on pushing, even after the polls and town halls and special-election outcomes made it clear the voters were going to push back?
Today, Ezra Klein made the case that the answer for liberals should be yes. A lot of Democratic politicians will lose their jobs tonight, he conceded. But ?if you see the point of politics as actually getting things done,? rather than just trying to preserve a majority for as many years as possible, ?the last two years, for Democrats, have been a stunning, historic success. Whatever else you can say about the 111th Congress, it got things done ? if [its members] failed as politicians, they succeeded as legislators. And legislating is, at least in theory, what they came to Washington to do.?
This is a powerful argument. Majorities come and go; big legislative achievements (and say what you will about the 111th Congress, but it wasn?t afraid to go big) can last a long, long time. Certainly there are many conservatives who wish that the Republican congresses of the Bush era had risked the public?s wrath to pass Social Security reform or tax reform, instead of playing it safe and eventually losing anyway amid the backlash against the Iraq War. Politics often gets covered as though the legislative sessions are just a long prelude to the real action of election season. But for all the breathless horse-race coverage, elections only matter to the extent that they produce (or forestall) actual legislation. And where the policies of the United States government are concerned, all the ground the Republicans regained tonight doesn?t change the fact that what liberals achieved in Barack Obama?s first two years in office was more consequential than any conservative victories in recent memory.
The question is what happens next. If the backlash persists into 2012, if the Republicans get serious about policy, if this cycle?s conservative gains are a prelude to conservative legislative successes down the road, then the Democrats? decision to gamble their majority on health care reform may come to look reckless and self-destructive, and the victories of the 111th Congress will seem pyrrhic rather than enduring.
But that?s a lot of ?if?s. For now, for tonight, Republicans need to keep a lid on their euphoria and recognize that while they?ve come out on top in this election, in the most important sense they haven?t won anything just yet.
http://douthat.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/11/02/was-it-worth-it/
